VB Commodore vs HZ Holden

Commodore Home

VB Commodore

HZ Holden

VB VC VH VK Commodore Repair Manual

Transition to a New Era

The HZ Holden represented the final iteration of Holden’s traditional full-size sedans, wagons, utilities, and panel vans, offering refinement, comfort, and V8 performance in Monaro and GTS variants. By 1978, Holden introduced the VB Commodore, marking a major transition from the classic Holden body style to a modern, mid-size platform inspired by the European Opel designs.

The VB Commodore represented a completely new approach for Holden: smaller, more modern, fuel-efficient, and aimed at a changing Australian market. It kept Holden’s performance DNA while bringing the brand into a new era of design and engineering.

Design and Styling Comparison

Exterior Design

HZ Holden:

  • Traditional full-size Holden body with muscular stance
  • Sedan, wagon, panel van, and utility variants
  • Chrome trim and styling details emphasized Deluxe, Special, and Monaro trims
  • Strong presence on the road with classic 1970s proportions

VB Commodore:

  • Modern mid-size design inspired by Opel Rekord, smaller and more aerodynamic
  • Sedan and station wagon variants introduced (utility followed later with WB)
  • Sleeker lines with less chrome, more European-inspired styling
  • Grille, headlights, and body panels more integrated and modern
  • Less bulky than HZ, aimed at better fuel economy and urban appeal

The VB Commodore looked noticeably more modern than the HZ, reflecting late-1970s design trends and a shift toward mid-size practicality.

Interior Design

HZ Holden:

  • Comfortable, spacious bench seating for six
  • Dashboard with clear instrumentation and functional layout
  • Interior trim upgraded in Deluxe, Special, and Monaro variants

VB Commodore:

  • Smaller, more driver-focused cabin
  • Modern dashboard with European-inspired instrument layout
  • Front bucket seats standard, optional center console
  • Interior quality improved with more refined finishes, particularly in SL/E trim
  • Cabin felt smaller but more modern and ergonomic than HZ

The VB interior was more contemporary and driver-focused, though less spacious than the traditional HZ Holden.

Platform and Engineering Changes

Chassis and Suspension:

  • HZ: Full-size perimeter frame, independent front suspension, leaf-spring rear
  • VB: Mid-size unibody chassis with MacPherson strut front suspension, coil spring rear
  • Improved ride comfort and handling for mid-size dimensions
  • Lighter and more fuel-efficient than HZ

Brakes and Safety:

  • HZ: Drum brakes front and rear, optional disc brakes
  • VB: Front disc brakes standard on higher trims, better braking performance
  • Safety features more modern, including improved seatbelt mounting and ergonomics

The VB provided a more modern, lighter, and agile driving experience compared to the HZ.

Engine and Drivetrain Comparison

HZ Holden Engines:

  • “Red” six-cylinder engines: 173, 202 cu in
  • V8 engines: 253, 308, 350 cu in (Monaro GTS 350)
  • Rear-wheel drive, three-speed manual, optional four-speed/floor shift

VB Commodore Engines:

  • “Red” six-cylinder engines: 186, 202 cu in
  • V8 engines: 253, 308
  • Rear-wheel drive retained
  • Three-speed manual or optional three-speed automatic

Performance Comparison:

  • HZ: Strong V8 performance, comfortable full-size driving
  • VB: Lighter and more responsive mid-size platform, V8 optional
  • VB emphasized efficiency and handling over outright size and power

Model Range Comparison

HZ Holden:

  • 2-door and 4-door sedans, wagon, panel van, utility
  • Deluxe, Special, Monaro, and GTS trims

VB Commodore:

  • 4-door sedan, 5-door wagon
  • Trim levels: SL, SL/E, and base models
  • Focused on modern mid-size comfort, economy, and practicality
  • Performance-oriented models introduced later in Monaro-based Commodore variants

The VB offered fewer body styles but represented a modern, practical, and efficient platform.

Technology and Features

HZ:

  • Functional dashboard, optional heater and radio
  • Basic controls, comfort and performance prioritized in higher trims

VB:

  • Modern dashboard layout, driver-focused controls
  • Optional heater, radio, and upgraded trim in SL/E
  • More ergonomic seats and controls
  • Lighter, more efficient platform improved driving comfort and handling

The VB interior emphasized modern ergonomics and driver comfort, a departure from HZ’s spacious traditional layout.

Driving Experience

HZ Holden:

  • Comfortable full-size ride, solid V8 performance
  • Spacious cabin, relaxed driving style
  • Strong presence on highways and urban roads

VB Commodore:

  • Lighter, more responsive mid-size handling
  • More agile in urban settings, easier to park
  • Sufficient power with six-cylinder engines; V8 optional for spirited performance
  • Cabin quieter and more modern, though less spacious than HZ

The VB was a shift toward modern, efficient, and agile driving while maintaining Holden’s performance DNA.

Reliability and Common Problems

HZ:

  • Very reliable, robust six-cylinder and V8 engines
  • Easy to maintain, classic mechanical simplicity

VB:

  • Reliable mid-size platform, lighter and easier to manage
  • Some early VB-specific parts harder to source
  • Overall mechanically simpler than modern vehicles, easier than later Commodores

Both models are dependable; VB introduced modern improvements and efficiency without sacrificing Holden reliability.

Ownership Costs Today

Purchase Price:

  • HZ: Classic full-size Holden, collectible, particularly Monaro variants
  • VB: Early Commodore, highly collectible as the start of a new generation

Parts Availability:

  • HZ: Limited, but many parts available for Monaro and V8 variants
  • VB: Parts limited but increasing interest from collectors

Running Costs:

  • HZ: Larger, heavier, less fuel-efficient
  • VB: Lighter, more efficient, cheaper to run, with optional V8 for enthusiasts

Collector and Enthusiast Value

HZ Holden:

  • Appreciated for classic 1970s styling and Monaro/GTS performance
  • Last of the traditional full-size Holdens

VB Commodore:

  • Extremely collectible as the first Commodore generation
  • Mid-size efficiency with European-inspired design
  • Early SL/E and optional V8 models sought-after by enthusiasts

Choose HZ if:

  • You want a classic full-size Holden with traditional style and V8 performance
  • You value classic 1970s design and presence

Choose VB if:

  • You want the first modern Commodore, with mid-size practicality and efficiency
  • You value a modernized driving experience and collectible status

Verdict – Which Is Better? The HZ Holden represented the peak of Holden’s traditional full-size sedans with comfort, space, and V8 performance. The VB Commodore marked a new era, offering a smaller, lighter, and more modern platform focused on efficiency, agility, and contemporary styling. For collectors, HZ is prized for classic full-size appeal and Monaro/GTS models, while VB Commodore is celebrated as the beginning of Holden’s modern mid-size era

VB VC VH VK Commodore Repair Manual

error: Content is protected !!